Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Friday, October 9, 2009
Calculations of Return (ROA vs ROE vs ROIC)
Return on assets (ROA), return on equity (ROE) and return on invested capital (ROIC) are the three most prevalent metrics used to obtain an idea of the returns a company generates, and to compare this return generation to the company’s peers. While important information can be learned from each one of these metrics, there are some significant differences between them.
ROA, calculated as net operating profit after tax (NOPAT) divided by total assets, shows the returns the company is able to generate relative to its entire asset base. While generally a good metric to use in comparing companies in same industries, this metric can be skewed when a company is holding lots of excess cash or assets for sale. These assets, while not expected to generate income are used in the calculation thereby causing the return on assets to appear lower than that which the company’s actual productive assets generate.
ROE, calculated as net income after tax divided by total equity (excluding preferred shares), demonstrates the percentage return earned on each dollar invested by the shareholders of the firm. This metric is very relevant when comparing companies with similar capital structures but outside of such a scenario it should not be relied upon. As Assets = Liabilities + Equity, the more debt a company has in its capital structure the smaller the equity will be as a percentage of total assets. Unlike the ROA metric, which remains stable throughout all capital structures, ROE can appear extremely high or extremely low when comparing a company to another employing a very different percentage of debt to equity.
My personal favorite of the three is ROIC, calculated as NOPAT divided by ‘operating net working capital plus operating fixed assets’. Operating fixed assets are any assets that are expected to contribute to earnings such as equipment, land (if not excess), goodwill, intangible assets, etc. Using operating net working capital, calculated as ‘current assets’ minus ‘excess cash’ minus ‘current liabilities’, also ensures that current assets that aren’t expected to generate earnings (such as excess cash) are not included in the calculation. This metric is my favorite as it gives a good indication of a company’s actual capacity to generate returns through utilization of its productive assets. Also, this metric can be used to compare companies employing varying capital structures. My main use of this metric is in comparing it to a company’s weighted average cost of capital (WACC), an estimation of the return expected by the debt and equity holders of the firm on a weighted average basis. The purpose of comparing the two is described in a previous article.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Don't Panic Sell, Beat Mr. Market
The markets MAY have started a long awaited correction today, but then again it's impossible to tell for sure. Know the value in the companies you own, don't panic sell, and use major dips in the market as buying opportunities.
By trying to time the market's daily fluctuations you are playing a game that you can not win. This is how people end up buying high and selling low; the exact opposite of what you want to do. So please, have conviction in the companies that you own. If something material changes in one of your holdings then re-evaluate but otherwise do not let "Mr. Market" faze you. If anything, I get a little excited on days like today because it means we may finally have some more buying opportunities than we've had for the past couple of months. You should have a list of companies you would like to own, and then when the market finally serves them to you on a silver platter for the price you've wanted to pay for them, take it. If the market continues to drop, then buy some more. Over the long-term you WILL beat Mr. Market this way.
Stay strong my friends... we may have some exciting weeks ahead.
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
Screening For Value
With so many companies to research out there how does one go about finding potential value stocks? Value investors tend to read a lot; Francis Chou has even been quoted as saying he reads upwards of 200 pages (newspapers, magazines, books, etc) every day. On top of daily reading it's important to have a resource to go to when you are fresh out of ideas and need that next company to take a deep dive into. This is where stock screeners are useful.
The best stock screener I have found to date is ADVFN. It is completely free and can screen US, Canadian and UK equities. Also, it has more fundamental criteria available than I've seen anywhere else. If there are any other screeners you are aware of I'd be grateful if you posted them in the comments for the readers, although I challenge you to find one better than ADVFN.
Following are some of my favourite criteria to screen for as well as the constraints I like to place on each:
- Gross Margin: I like a gross margin of at least 20%, this ensures that the company has the ability to alter pricing in order to push through competition and difficult times.
- Inventory/Sales: Industry specific, but you don't want the inventory turns to be too low, especially if you are placing a significant value on tangible assets - the longer the inventory sits for, the more uncertain its value will be.
- Net Cash from Continuing Operations: While GAAP earnings may be negative, these companies can still possibly be cash flow positive. I would be wary of any business that does not show positive cash from operations as they will just be eating into their cash asset and you can't predict for how long.
- Current Ratio: Must be greater than 1 otherwise the company does not have the ability to meet its current obligations. In a market like this where funding is increasingly difficult to raise this is a situation companies should be trying to avoid.
- Price to Earnings Ratio: I like P/E to be less than the long-term market average of 15. This is a good indication that the company may be undervalued, but the specific industry also needs to be considered.
- Price to Book Ratio: I keep this under 2, depending on what I am searching for, just to screen out those companies that are most likely overvalued. There are companies that warrant a premium price/book but these companies will also have a high return on capital, so you will tailor your screen to look specifically for those.
- Price to Tangible Book Ratio: Interesting companies can be found if this criteria is set to less than 1. These will also most likely be companies in distress however so they should be approached with caution.
- Return on Invested Capital: You can set this to be below your estimate of average cost of capital to find those with turnaround potential. Another option is to set this variable greater than your estimate of average cost of capital and combine it with a screen for companies with low Price to Book in order to find companies that are likely trading below fair value.
- Long Term Debt to Total Capital: I set this to a max of 60% and then I evaluate based on the specific company I find. Some industries, those with steady cash flows, can safely service high levels of debt. Then there are those with more variable cash flows that should keep debt to a minimum. Over 60% however is likely getting close to the upper limit of safety for any company.
- Sector: If you want to incorporate a top down view into your investments then screening by sector can be a rewarding way to significantly narrow the options.
- Institutional/Insider Holdings: I usually don't set restrictions for these variables but I do like having them available so that I can get an idea of share ownership. For example, when looking for stocks with turnaround potential I would be hesitant to invest in a company with low institutional and insider holding as no one has an incentive to get the job done.
The above criteria are not always used concurrently. If they were, many times you won't find any companies appearing on the list. Part of the fun of a stock screener is to experiment, play around and see what you find. Different combinations of the above criteria among others, and their individual constraints, will yield different results.
I hope this is helpful in your search for value. As always, I welcome your thoughts and comments and I encourage you to share your own criteria for screening.
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
A Value Investor Is What I Choose To Be
We've had a lot of new visitors this week coming from various referrals on the web, and other sites where my articles are syndicated. I just wanted to take this opportunity and say welcome. It is my hope that you find this site to be a useful resource whether you are an experienced investor or just getting started. I recommend subscribing to the RSS feed (the orange button to the right) in order to receive the latest posts as they become available. Some articles, especially investment ideas, may be time sensitive and RSS is the best way to get them right away.
The articles and information on this site tend to be focused on the value style of investing as that is what I practice myself and is what I know best as a result. Very important however, especially if you are new to investing, is to pick a style/methodology, learn it well and stick to it. The worst losses in the stock market come from letting your emotions dictate your buy/sell decisions. That is when you are most likely to buy high and sell low; exactly what you do not want to be doing. As a value investor I have a lot of conviction in the value investment philosophy. I definitely do not preach it to be the only way to invest and there are certainly many very successful investors from other disciplines. Over the past few years however I have followed practitioners, read research and conducted some of my own studies. What I have learned is that there truly is a significant and persistent premium attributed to value investing over time and as a result this is the style I am practicing, preaching and most importantly sticking to.
The best place to get started on this site is by clicking on the "basics" heading under the topics to the left. This series of articles will give you a brief introduction to the investment methodology which I utilize. Just as there are many value investors out there, there are also many ways to practice value investing. The methodology I use, which I studied with Dr. George Athanassakos (Ben Graham Chair in Value Investing at the University of Western Ontario) while pursuing an MBA, is based largely on the teachings of Bruce Greenwald at Columbia Business School. A great resource for additional information on this methodology is Bruce Greenwald's book - Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond.
Please let me know either through the comments or via email (jonathan at jonathangoldberg dot com) if you have any suggestions for content that you would like to see here and I will do my best to accommodate. In the past I have posted investment ideas, summaries of lectures by notable value investors, market commentary and research findings (of which I admit may be the driest of the bunch i.e. last post). Speaking of research findings, while very dry my last post is an excerpt from a study I have conducted and the excerpt gives a great overview of some important studies which you can research on your own. For those of you that choose to skip that post I hope to have a more "user friendly" post in the future summarizing the findings as well as their applicability to you and your investments.
Look around, read previous posts and think about what you'd like to see in the future. And most importantly, subscribe to the RSS feed to the right of this page so that you are kept up to date with my posts as they become available. Oh yeah, and tell your friends to visit too!
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
Liquidating the Balance Sheet
As mentioned in my basics course on value investing, the first step I take in valuing a company is discovering its net asset value. That is, the value per share of the company’s assets after accounting for (subtracting) all liabilities. If the company is healthy, and operates in a viable industry, the assets should be marked to their replacement value. These assets need to be replenished as they are used and any competitor wanting to enter the industry would need to pay fair market value in order to acquire similar assets. This replacement value is the normal case and would then be followed by an analysis of earnings power value, as discussed on this site previously.
What if the company is in trouble? Perhaps the company is in imminent threat of default and is not expected to continue normal operations into the future. Earnings power analysis is then useless as we can expect the company to liquidate its assets in order to pay debtors, with holders of common equity receiving the leftovers. In this case the assets of the company should be valued at liquidation value. We assume all assets are to be sold off to the highest bidder. Liabilities are then subtracted from the value of these assets to find what would remain for the holders of common equity.
As value investors, we don’t only consider companies that have long-term holding potential. Value investing is about buying an asset for less than it is worth. In some instances this may involve purchasing a company facing bankruptcy if the investor has conviction that the assets will be worth more to the common equity holder after liquidation than they can currently be purchased for, always including an appropriate margin of safety.
Valuing assets at liquidation requires a great deal of expertise and may require the services of an expert valuator. Keeping some things in mind, however, should assist you in arriving at a reasonable estimate when needed.
- Asset liquidity. The more liquid the assets are, the more likely they are to be sold at book value. For instance, cash is always valued at book value even in the case of liquidation. Marketable securities are another example of a highly liquid asset.
- Failing business vs failed industry. If the business being liquidated operates within a thriving industry then you can expect that there may be competitors willing to purchase the assets. In the case of a non-viable industry however, assets on the balance sheet are more likely to be sold at scrap prices.
- Asset specialization/customization. The pool of potential buyers shrinks the more specialized or customized the asset being sold. A warehouse that is just a stock space for storing items will have many potential buyers and will likely be sold at close to fair value (given a decent real estate market and enough time to sell). On the other hand, a warehouse that has been custom built and designed to house specific types of goods needing special care will likely be sold at far below replacement or fair value in the case of liquidation. It is important to keep industry conditions in mind though as even in the case of very specialized assets on the balance sheet, these assets could have a fair chance at being purchased closer to their replacement value if the industry is viable. In the case of a thriving industry, competitors will likely be bidding to purchase the asset in order to acquire the extra capacity on the market.
While valuing balance sheet assets at liquidation value can be a difficult task, keeping the above concepts in mind should assist you in arriving at a realistic estimate of their value. Best of luck, and as always I will do my best to respond promptly to questions and/or comments posted below.
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
Boost Returns By Selling Options
Options can be a very useful tool to boost your portfolio's returns. While options can be very risky when used to speculate, this isn't necessarily the case when using options backed by stocks you would like to own or which you already own.
Value investors looking for increased returns to their portfolios can employ two options strategies. One is selling covered calls, and the other is selling naked puts.
Being "covered" means that you already own the asset needed to fulfill the obligation of the call option if exercised. Your downside is limited as a result. A "call" means that the purchaser of the contract has the right to purchase the stocks specified from the seller at the exercise price (upon expiry if the market price is at or above the exercise price).
As a value investor you want to hold onto your investments until they approach your estimate of the intrinsic value. Depending on the situation this can take from a few months to a few years. By selling covered calls at your estimate of intrinsic value you receive the premium from the contracts and only need to sell the actual stocks if they reach their fair value by expiry. If this doesn't happen you can employ the process repeatedly, generating a steady stream of premiums.
A "naked" option means that you are left exposed to unknown downside risk in the event that the option is exercised. A "put" means that the purchaser of the contract has the right to sell the stocks specified to the seller at the exercise price (upon expiry if the market price is at or below the exercise price).
By selling naked puts, the value investor is committing himself to purchase a security only if the market price at expiry is at or below the exercise price of the contract. If a security that you would like to own is currently trading at too high of a price then by selling naked puts you essentially earn a premium today and only need to purchase the stock if it reaches your entry price or below by expiry.
As shown above, the contract sold for a covered call should have an exercise price equal to or slightly below your estimate of intrinsic value and the exercise price of a naked put should be equal to your desired entry price. The last decision is the time until expiry, which is a personal choice. The longer the option has until expiry the more valuable it will be, but it also exposes the seller to the risk that something material may change within the company during this time. If a material event impacts your estimate of intrinsic value then you may be contracted to sell or purchase stocks at prices you no longer want to. As a general rule, puts can be sold for a long time out if you believe the company to be stable with changes to intrinsic value (on the downside) being unlikely. Selling calls far into the future however may cause you to hold onto a security well passed the time it reaches intrinsic value, perhaps causing you to miss a window of opportunity to sell if market fluctuations bring the price back down.
The risk involved in these strategies is that you may be either a) forced to purchase a stock for more than the market price (in the case of a put) or b) forced to sell a stock for less than it is currently trading in the market (in the case of a call). Either way, if you are confident in the intrinsic value you determined for the company then you are no worse off than if you didn't sell options but rather purchased and sold the stocks according to your stringent entry and exit points. In fact you are better off, because with options you've earned the premiums.
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Waiting for the Right Time to Buy
In my last post I talked about potential buying opportunities in the near future that you might want to be ready for. Part of being ready for a pullback in the market is to have your valuations and company knowledge on standby and ready for when you should take action. Not every company I value will be an immediate "buy". As a matter of fact, most of a value investor's time may be spent valuing companies that are not attractive opportunities at their immediate market price. I still see value in bringing these companies to your attention however; as once you do the work to value a company I definitely recommend keeping it on your radar screen. You're done the hard part, now keep your model updated and wait for the right time to pounce.
If you're a knowledgeable investor you can even profit off of the work you've done to value a company that you aren't ready to buy. This can be accomplished through the writing of options, which will be discussed in a future post.
Saturday, August 8, 2009
Do Value Investors Add Value?
The methodology discussed in the basics course on value investing must seem like a lot of work to implement. Many of you may be wondering if it is even worth implementing when you have no doubt read the benefits of merely investing in pre-screened (according to P/E, P/BV, etc) value stocks. Dr. George Athanassakos, my mentor and Ben Graham Chair in Value Investing at the Richard Ivey School of Business (University of Western Ontario), has written a paper with two former students, Reyer Barel and Saj Karsan, on the added premium resulted in through the additional valuation work. In this paper they compare a basket of stocks selected merely using the "academic" method of screening for low P/E and low P/BV, and a basket of stocks selected using the rigorous and time intensive process which value investors follow.
Athanassakos et al find that there was a significant value premium attributed to the basket of low P/E and P/BV stocks as compared to a basket of high P/E and P/BV stocks. This has been confirmed by other research as well. What is unique about this paper is that there was an even greater and significant value premium attributed to the basket of stocks that went a step beyond the screening process and used a "valuation technology" to find the truly undervalued of the low P/E and low P/BV basket.
The methodology used in the study is the exact methodology that I learnt under Dr. Athanassakos so not only is the paper an interesting read but it is also a great way to obtain additional insights on valuation from an expert in the field.
The students that worked on this paper with Dr. Athanassakos have a value investing site of their own, Barel Karsan. The site is an inspiration for this one and it offers up very interesting insights into the philosophy and investing in general. While ramping up slowly due to my ongoing search for employment, I hope that one day my own site will live up to the one that inspired it.
Details on the paper are below and the paper can be found HERE.
Athanassakos, G., Barel, R., Karsan, S., 2009, “Do Value Investors Add Value? Searching for and Finding Value: Canadian Evidence 1999-2007”, Working Paper, May 2009.
My Mentor - Dr. George Athanassakos
What I have shown you in the basics course on value investing should only be considered as a first look into the philosophy and how to implement it. As you can imagine, every value investor has their own metrics, views and opinions when it comes to valuation and you will develop your own methodology with study and practice. A good place to start is with the book by Bruce Greenwald that I have mentioned previously. Now this is just a start.
My own serious studies in value investing began while working on a research paper with Dr. George Athanassakos at the Richard Ivey School of Business (University of Western Ontario), where he is the Ben Graham Chair in Value Investing. While at the school I also took his highly regarded and greatly subscribed to course in value investing. In this course we spent a number of intense weeks valuing many companies in different industries so that Dr. Athanassakos' methodology would be second nature to us. On this site I will be sticking to the overview of the methodology that I have posted and will not be getting into the intricacies as our focus here will be about investment ideas. In order to learn the detailed aspects of valuation, that I use to arrive at these ideas, along with the toolkit to then go off and develop your own methodology I definitely recommend studying with an expert in the field like Dr. Athanassakos.
Dr. Athanassakos offers executive education seminars in value investing during the year. Details on these can be found HERE. He also teaches value investing to the MBA and HBA students at the Richard Ivey School of Business (University of Western Ontario).
Saturday, August 1, 2009
Bruce Greenwald Interview
I recently found an excellent interview with Bruce Greenwald that I recommend reading, especially if you've been following my basics course on value investing. Over the past few weeks I have been taking you through a brief overview of a value investing methodology. In this interview Mr. Greenwald does an excellent job of explaining the necessity of following such a methodology. He sums up value investing into three things; a search process and an understanding of the extent to which markets are inefficient, a "technology" for valuing what you are considering buying, and having discipline and patience.
"So I think of value investing as three things. A search strategy, which we talked about, which is where the low P/E, low market to book comes in. But it's not all of it, by any means, even of the search strategy. A valuation strategy. And a discipline approach to taking advantage of the information that your valuation is telling you about and having a default strategy when it's telling you it doesn't look like there's anything there."
The beauty of this is that your valuation "technology" will enable you to have the discipline and patience that is required of a value investor. As he says, if you believe in your valuation and the stock you just purchased goes down, then you will buy more! In this way instead of getting caught up in the same behavioral mistakes that the average investor makes, you are taking advantage of a good deal turning into a better one as you cost-average down.
Mr. Greenwald also does a great job of explaining the importance of each step in the methodology that I have shown you, as well as the importance of the order in which they are performed.
"What you want to do is to have a technology that brings all the available information to bear, so you can cross-correlate the asset values with the earnings-power values, with your judgment about whether there's a franchise here. That if you're going to buy growth, you're absolutely certain that the franchise is there so the growth is going to be valuable... And then, only then, looking at the growth."
I highly recommend reading the interview which can be found HERE. Following is a brief biography of Bruce Greenwald as found in the Columbia Business School directory:
Professor Bruce C. N. Greenwald holds the Robert Heilbrunn Professorship of Finance and Asset Management at Columbia Business School and is the academic Director of the Heilbrunn Center for Graham & Dodd Investing. Described by the New York Times as "a guru to Wall Street's gurus," Greenwald is an authority on value investing with additional expertise in productivity and the economics of information.Greenwald has been recognized for his outstanding teaching abilities. He has been the recipient of numerous awards, including the Columbia University Presidential Teaching Award which honors the best of Columbia's teachers for maintaining the University's longstanding reputation for educational excellence. His classes are consistently oversubscribed, with more than 650 students taking his courses every year in subjects such as Value Investing, Economics of Strategic Behavior, Globalization of Markets, and Strategic Management of Media.
Friday, July 31, 2009
The Value of Growth
This is the last part of the basics series on value investing. The series in its entirety can be accessed by clicking on the "basics" link under the topics section to the left. I hope this has lent a comfortable understanding of the value investing methodology. I can always be reached with questions or comments via email at "jonathan (at) jonathangoldberg (dot) com".
In the coming articles I hope to introduce you to a wealth of value investment opportunities and insights to continue to further your education in the field (and to put some money in your pocket at the same time). If there are any companies you feel may be value investments please email me with your suggestions as I may do a complete valuation and analysis along with recommendation. In comparing my notes with yours we may both learn a thing or two.
I do not profess to be an expert in the field, as my learning is ongoing, so I welcome any suggestions for topics as well as additional insights into items which may have been discussed previously.
Subscribing to the RSS feed via the orange button to the right is the best way to stay on top of new articles as I do not plan on posting each day... and some days I may even surprise you with a second helping. Thank you for reading, please continue and enjoy the ride!
---------------
Valuing growth is the least reliable aspect of a valuation. Whereas with the net asset valuation we are valuing assets the company currently owns and with the earnings power valuation we are extrapolating already realized earnings, in valuing growth we are forecasting what we think will happen in the future. It is this forecasting which is highly sensitive to assumptions as well as other behavioral biases. One of these behavioral biases is the fact that investors tend to overpay for growth; the average investor may jump into a stock that everyone likes (also known as "herding") or assume that they know more about the the stock and its future than they actually do. As Mark Twain said, "It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so."
As value investors we want this growth for free. Sure we are willing to consider a stock more favorably because of the potential for growth, but we won't pay for something that we know to be so highly sensitive to assumptions. The most we are willing to pay for a security would be EPV (in the case of a franchise value with growth) - in such a case the value of growth is our margin of safety.
Unless a company meets the following two criteria there is just no way that value investors can consider it to have potential for growth:
- Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) must be greater than the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), otherwise growth has no value.
- The company must have a fully sustainable competitive advantage otherwise ROIC can not remain greater than WACC.
The valuation of a company that meets the above criteria for growth has two aspects which are different than our basic valuation, as follows:
1. Expenses that support growth need to be added back to the free cash flows that have been calculated. This includes items such as the growth portion of an R&D expense and the growth portion of a marketing expense. These are added back to the cash flows prior to removing taxes (at the EBIT line). We do this in order to adjust EBIT to earnings without growth, the same earnings we try to capture in each valuation.
2. EPV is modified by a multiplier for the value of growth. The equation to arrive at this multiplier can be found using some "valuation algebra" as shown in this book (the details of the multiplier are too in depth for this basics course but may be discussed in a future article). If the growth rate assumption used in the multiplier is reasonable and the modified EPV minus an appropriate margin of safety is greater than the original EPV, we would pay full EPV per share for the company at the most. If the modified EPV minus the margin of safety is less than the original EPV, we would pay at most the modified EPV minus the margin of safety. In this way we are obtaining the growth prospects of the company for free as we are merely substituting these prospects for the (or part of the) margin of safety.
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Margin of Safety
As mentioned in earlier posts, value investors like to make use of assumptions that they can be relatively certain about (i.e. last twelve months' earnings, balance sheet valuations, etc). Even so, we know that nothing ever plays out as one would expect. As such, we make use of a "margin of safety". This means that we will never buy into a security at its full intrinsic value (unless there are some pretty certain growth prospects which will be discussed in the next post).
Once the intrinsic value is calculated, an appropriate margin of safety is considered in order to arrive at an entry price. If the security can be had for less than this entry price it should be purchased.
---------------
For those readers that are just joining us now, this is the 5th installment of a "basics" course on value investing. This is important preparatory reading, especially if you are very new to value investing, in order to understand valuations which will be discussed on this site. You can access the entire course by clicking on the "basics" link under the topics heading to the left. I also recommend subscribing to this site's RSS feed by clicking the orange link to the right.
The next post will discuss the value of growth and will conclude the posts on value investing basics. There will definitely be more educational posts in the future but these 6 articles are the basics required in order to understanding an investment thesis on this site.
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Intrinsic Value
The intrinsic value (IV) of a potential investment is arrived at by comparing the results of the Net Asset Value (NAV) and Earnings Power Value (EPV) analyses.
If EPV is less than NAV then the intrinsic value for the company is derived from EPV and adds value for the probability of a catalyst taking place within the company that would bring the value of the company to its competitive state (NAV).
If EPV is equal to NAV then it would seem that the company being studied has no competitive advantage. Therefore, EPV and NAV would define the intrinsic value.
If EPV is greater than NAV then the company has what is referred to as a "franchise value". To be willing to pay for this franchise value, the investor must deem it to be sustainable. In this case the intrinsic value is derived from NAV plus added value for the probability of the company maintaining its franchise.
Monday, July 27, 2009
Earnings Power Value
Earnings Power Value (EPV) is an estimate of the value of a company from its ongoing operations. The beauty of EPV, for value investors, is that the numbers used to calculate it are NO GROWTH free cash flows. No growth free cash flows just mean that we are only subtracting from cash flows the amount of capital expenditure required to sustain the business. By using no growth free cash flows we eliminate, to a great degree, attempts to predict future growth and as such arrive at a number which we can be fairly certain of; we are using today's earnings, with the assumption that current profitability is sustainable. This isn't to say that some companies can't expect significant growth, but as value investors we refuse to pay for it.
Though we are using today's earnings (today's no growth free cash flows) in calculating EPV, we are normalizing these earnings to the business cycle. This eliminates the effects on profitability of valuing the firm at different points in the business cycle. Ideally, this means that we are considering the average operating profit (as a percentage of total sales) over 5-8 years. This average would then be applied to current sales. Other adjustments to be made to the current year's cash flows would be to account for average expected one-time gains/losses.
The final step in calculating EPV is to divide the final cash flow number by the cost of capital. This gives us the present value of a perpetuity without any estimation of growth. That is your EPV.
Unlike net asset value (NAV) which is an equity value, the EPV result is the enterprise value of the firm; that is, adjustments need to be made to trim this down to equity value. In the investment articles on this site, EPV will refer to the equity value (per share) resulting from an EPV analysis.
Saturday, July 11, 2009
Net Asset Value
Determining a figure for the replacement value of the balance sheet is the first step I take in arriving at the value I would pay for a company. This includes marking up land and buildings to current market values, adding assets and liabilities for operating leases, as well as adding intangible assets such as customer relations, product portfolio and licenses. Once complete, simply subtract the liabilities from the assets to find the net asset value (NAV) of the company. Dividing this by the number of shares outstanding yields the NAV per share.
This NAV is what you would expect an optimally performing company in the industry to be worth. All assets would be bid to their fair value in a perfectly competitive environment. That is, in a perfectly competitive environment an optimally performing company's ROIC would be equal to its WACC.
Now in the real world the NAV of a company is not necessarily equal to its actual worth. There will be companies that are under-utilizing their assets (will be worth less than NAV) as well as companies that hold a franchise value (worth more than NAV as they are not in "perfect" competition). As such, the next step is to find the earning power of a company in order to arrive at a value based on actual cash flows. This will be discussed next.
Wednesday, July 8, 2009
ROIC vs. WACC
Over the next couple of posts I will be providing you with the basic knowledge you need in order to understand my value investing methodology. Also, if you haven't done so already you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed so that you receive the posts as they are published (link is to the right). Think of this as a mini-lesson in value investing. Enjoy!
---------------
Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) is one of the first things I calculate in order to get a sense of whether or not management is taking the company in the right direction. ROIC is essentially the return that the company generates via its invested capital.
While this is obviously a useful metric to compare a company against its peers, as mentioned, I like to use this in order to look inside the company itself and see if management's actions are taking the company in the right direction. In order to do this I compare ROIC against the company's Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). This is my estimation of the company's cost of capital to the equity and debt holders, on a weighted average basis.
If ROIC is greater than WACC then we can assume that growth adds value. On the other hand, if ROIC is less than WACC then value is actually destroyed as the company invests more capital; for every dollar of investment the company attracts it pays out more than it earns with it. In the latter case we would want to see management improve the company's ROIC before investing any more capital. Ideally, the company would actually sell non-performing assets in order to get ROIC in line with WACC.
Just because a company's ROIC is less than its WACC does not make it a poor investment. If management is committed to divesting non-performing assets and improving the return on the capital currently employed, and you feel there is a great possibility of them succeeding, then it may be just the investment opportunity you have been waiting for.
Tuesday, July 7, 2009
Short Video on Value Investing
I just stumbled upon this video which was made by Columbia Business School. It features Bruce C. Greenwald - the Robert Heilbrunn Professor of Finance and Asset Management - speaking and lecturing about value investing. It is definitely worth the 5 minute viewing in my opinion, no matter what your level of knowledge. Always nice to see someone so passionate about value investing as motivation to stick to the discipline.
Over the following weeks you can look forward to insights and valuations on some stocks I have been following. I have had some interviews this week so didn't have time to do such posts justice but I can't wait to share my opinions with all of you.
Thursday, July 2, 2009
Value in Bonds
As I'm in the midst of a job search I haven't dedicated as much time as I would have liked to getting this blog started. I'm hoping to increase the frequency of posts as I am able. In the meantime you may consider subscribing to the RSS feed so that you automatically receive new posts.
---------------
Market prices for fixed income securities can be volatile just like those for equities, especially for those bonds with longer maturities. As you may be aware, Benjamin Graham describes bargain issues as those stocks and bonds particularly worthy of a security analyst's investigation. In terms of bonds these bargain issues are bonds that are deemed to be safe investments but which still sell at so low a price "as to offer a chance of considerable enhancement in market value". This is why we want to find bonds of a higher quality which are trading at a discount to bonds of a lower quality. In most cases bonds would be trading cheaply because their safety is questionable but this is not always the case. As in equities, there are always a small number of cases where a security may be trading at a discount while still meeting strict investment standards. Fundamentals still reign supreme in fixed income though, so not only do you want a company that may have been battered by the market and investor sentiment (even if correlated with a higher yield on the fixed income security), but you want to be confident that your contrarian views are correct. The bonds are only valuable so long as the company is still in existence!
The concept of finding value in fixed income securities is relatively straightforward, but where do we begin to look for these bargains? If the equities of certain companies may have been negatively affected, creating value opportunities within the equity market, then perhaps the fixed income securities of these companies may be a good place to start. As there is no apparent systematic way to segment corporate bonds into value and growth categories, The Brandes Institute went back to a study they conducted on equities and then studied the bonds that the companies in the study had issued. Their main findings were as follows:
- There were more issuers with debt outstanding within the value companies.
- The bonds issued by companies within the value group delivered a better total return than the bonds issued by the growth companies over subsequent 3 year periods from 1990 to 2007.
What is interesting from the findings of the study is that one would assume the difference in total return to be merely due to the value bonds' lower average credit rating and subsequently higher average spread. As such, The Brandes Institute compared the Lehman Brothers U.S. Aggregate Corporate A Index (a proxy for bonds of the growth companies which had a credit rating of "A" on average) to the Lehman Brothers U.S. Aggregate Corporate BAA Index (a proxy for bonds of the value companies which had a credit rating of "BBB+" on average). Over the same period as the study, these indices showed a difference in total returns of 14 basis points versus the approximately 69 basis point annualized total return difference between the value and growth bonds in the Brandes Institute study. The total return advantage for bonds of value companies therefore can not be fully explained by credit quality or yield spread.
It's difficult, if not impossible, for a retail investor to build a bond portfolio with adequate diversification. Perhaps there would be demand for a fixed income ETF that invests solely in the fixed income of the low price-to-earnings universe of stocks, which is commonly used as a generalization for the universe of value stocks.
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Ups and Downs of the Business Cycle
I do not recommend trying to time the market. Once again - I do NOT recommend timing the market. That being said there are benefits to knowing where we are in the business cycle.
From a value perspective what I look for first and foremost is the discount to a company's intrinsic value that their stock is trading at. This card trumps all as the company that leaves you the greatest margin for error should outperform in the long-run. Assuming all else being equal, including the discount to intrinsic value, there are times when I would select one investment over another. Look at today's markets for instance, we are most definitely somewhere around the trough of the business cycle. As the markets begin to improve we can expect a resurgence of inflation as demand returns and rates (which are now at historic lows) revert to the long-run average. At a time like this I would rather hold resource producers that will benefit from commodity price inflation. On the other hand, I would stay away from consumer goods manufacturers who will be susceptible to the rising input prices and may have competitive pressures which will keep them from raising prices to compensate. Financial companies would also perform poorly in an inflationary environment as rates rise and cut into their profits.
As mentioned before, this is only one of the many considerations that would go into comparing one investment option to another. If one company looks like the greater value play and has comparable long term prospects then the short term implications of the business cycle would not play a major part of the decision. This brings me to the next implication for this topic on value investing. When valuing a company it is a good idea to normalize earnings over an entire business cycle. As value investors we take a long term horizon and the value of a company relies in large part on profits that are expected many years into the future. As such, the next few years in the business cycle should not play much importance in the investment decision. It is important to make sure that you don't "anchor" your future expectations on recent boom or bust years. By normalizing profits over an entire business cycle we enable our valuation to take a realistic long-term view of the profits a company can be expected to make without incorporating a bias from the most recent reporting periods. As long term investors we are concerned with the long-term path of the economy and not the short term booms and busts that give rise to great investment opportunities.
Saturday, May 30, 2009
First Post - Recommended Reading
It's pouring rain outside as I sit here and listen to the thunder and the occasional wail of sirens passing by... what better time for my first post! To introduce myself; I am a 25 year old student of value investing and, while I will surely get older and more knowledgeable, I will also always remain a student of this investment philosophy. Having been only formally introduced to value investing within the past year, at MBA school, I am already a devout follower in and believer of the philosophy. During the past year I have read countless journal articles and research papers on value investing - I have even valued a company or two (quite the understatement). The goal of this inaugural post is to start you, the reader, on the path of enlightenment. Following are a list of journal articles and working papers that I recommend you read in order to help you pursue a value investment methodology with the discipline that is required. If you are currently enrolled in a post-secondary institution then you can likely access the journal articles through your school's library. The working papers listed can be found via the Social Science Research Network (SSRN).
- Abhyankar, A., Ho, K., Zhao, H., Value versus Growth: Stochastic Dominance Criteria, Working Paper, 2006.
- Arshanapalli, B., and Nelson, W.B., Small Cap and Value Investing Offer both High Returns and a Hedge, The Journal of Wealth Management, Spring 2007.
- Athanassakos, G., Portfolio Rebalancing and the January Effect in Canada, Financial Analysts Journal, Vol. 48, No. 6, Nov. – Dec., 1992, pp. 67-78.
- Athanassakos, G., Value vs. Growth Stock Returns and the Value Premium: The Canadian Experience 1985-2002, Working Paper, 2006.
- Bauman, W.S., and Miller, R.E., Investor Expectations and the Performance of Value Stocks versus Growth Stocks, Journal of Portfolio Management, Spring 1997.
- Capaul, C., Rowley, I., Sharpe, W.F., International Value and Growth Stock Returns, Financial Analysts Journal, Vol. 49, No. 1, Jan. – Feb., 1993, pp. 27-36.
- Chan, L.K.C., and Lakonishok, J., Value and Growth Investing: Review and Update, Financial Analysts Journal, January/February 2004.
- Fama, E.F., and French, K.R., Value versus Growth: The International Evidence, The Journal of Finance, Vol. 53, No. 6, Dec. 1998, pp. 1975-1999.
- Kao, D., and Shumaker, R.D., Equity Style Timing, Financial Analysts Journal, Vol. 55, No. 1, Jan. – Feb., 1999, pp. 37-48.
- Lakonishok, J., Shleifer, A., Vishny, R.W., Contrarian Investment, Extrapolation, and Risk, The Journal of Finance, Vol. 49, No. 5, Dec. 1994, pp. 1541-1578.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
